Items
of Interest
The
Market
MANHATTAN
POSTS 4TH QUARTER GAINS
In the
final quarter of 2007, the Manhattan real estate market continued
to see increased price levels and sales with declining inventory
as compared with the same period last year, according to a report
by the Miller Samuel appraisal firm for Prudential Douglas Elliman.
The greatest price gains were in larger apartments, specifically
two- and three-bedroom units, which averaged respective growth
of 22.1 percent and 39.8 percent since 2006. A portion of the
increase in price was attributed to an increase in the size of
the units sold. For all apartments, the median sales price increased
6.4 percent to $850,000 over the prior year quarter result of
$799,000, but it was1.7 percent below the preceding quarter's
$864,397. The average price per square foot increased 18.2 percent
to a record $1,180 over the prior year quarter result of $998;
it was 3.1 percent above the previous quarter's $1,144. Inflated
by an influx of very high-end condos such as 15 Central Park West
and the Plaza Hotel, the average sales price grew by 17.6 percent
to a record $1,439,909 since the last quarter of 2006 and by 5.1
percent over the third quarter of 2007. For more on the fourth
quarter, see the story below. And for even more details, click
here.
A
RESPECTED INDEX RECORDS FAST AND WIDE DECLINES
The decline
in home prices accelerated and spread to more regions of the country
in October, says the New York Times. Prices fell 6.1 percent from
October 2006 in 20 large metropolitan areas, according to Standard
& Poor's/Case-Shiller indexes, compared with a 4.9 percent
decline in September. (The indexes omit condo sales.) On a monthly
basis, prices fell 1.4 percent in October, the fastest they have
declined in at least the last seven years. All but three of the
20 regions experienced a fall in real estate values, and even
the three areas where prices were up from a year ago - Seattle,
Portland, Ore., and Charlotte - had a decline from a month earlier.
"We are in uncharted territory," said Yale economist
Robert J. Shiller. "This was the biggest housing boom we
have ever seen." By his calculation, the decline in home
prices is greater than at any time since 1941, when the housing
market was faltering at the start of the American entry in World
War II. Since their peak in July 2006, home prices in the 20 regions
have dropped 6.6 percent. Many economists are predicting that
home prices will fall 10 percent to 15 percent from their peak
to their trough, though some pessimists say the drop could be
as much as 30 percent. Prices are dropping fastest in the Midwest,
which has been hit hard by job losses in manufacturing, and in
California, Florida and the Southwest, where the housing boom
was most pronounced. Prices have fallen the most in Miami (down
12.4 percent from a year ago), Tampa (11.8 percent) and Detroit
(11.2 percent). Prices also are falling in the nation's
two largest metropolitan areas, Los Angeles (8.8 percent) and
New York (4.1 percent). "It suggests to me that the psychological
factor is very important," Shiller said. "Even in
cities that are doing well, people see what is going on nationwide
and they don't want to bid as much."
NEW-HOME
SALES PLUNGE TO 12-YEAR LOW IN NOVEMBER
That
is the slowest pace since April 1995, says to the New York Times.
New-home purchases are down 34.4 percent from a year earlier,
according to the U.S. Commerce Department; it was the biggest
year-over-year drop since January 1991 and leaves a large, if
shrinking, inventory of unsold homes to be worked off before the
glut can be dissipated. "Right now there is a huge gulf
between what buyers are willing to pay for a house and what sellers
are willing to take for it," said Mark Vitner, senior economist
at Wachovia. "People are sitting on the sidelines for a
good reason," added Patrick Newport, an economist at Global
Insight, an economic research firm in Lexington, Mass. "You're
taking a big risk because the asset you are buying may depreciate
a lot between now and a year from now." Analysts say home
sales could bottom out as early as the middle of 2008 but any
recovery will be gradual. "The laws of supply and demand
will work," Vitner said. "We built around 800,000
more units of housing than the market needed. It's going
to take us a couple of years of reduced home construction in order
to clear up its excess." Statistically, the size of the
slump is staggering, the Times continues. In the summer of 2005,
annual sales of new single-family homes hit a high of 1.39 million.
They have since dropped to an annual rate of 647,000 - a loss
of 53.4 percent. The current decline is the steepest peak-to-trough
drop since the 1982 housing bust, said Michael T. Darda, chief
economist at MKM Partners, and it could grow steeper if sales
continue to flag. "With prices going down and income continuing
to grow, that's helped to push up affordability,"
he suggested, saying that the industry appeared to be coming closer
to "the lows of this cycle."
WITH
PRICES FALLING, EXISTING-HOME SALES ARE RISING
Total
November sales of previously owned homes - including single-family,
townhomes, condominiums and co-ops - rose 0.4 percent from October
to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 5 million units, according
to the National Association of Realtors (NAR). That amount was
20 percent below one year earlier. "Near term, existing-home
sales should continue to hover in a narrow range, just as they
have since September, and that's good news because it'll
be a further sign that the housing market is stabilizing,"
commented NAR Chief Economist Lawrence Yun. "Mortgage interest
rates are near historic lows, and the most current data shows
decelerating price declines along with a modest reduction in the
number of homes on the market." The national median existing-home
price for all housing types was $210,200 in November, down 3.3
percent from the previous November, when it was $217,300. Meanwhile,
total housing inventory declined 3.6 percent at the end of November
to 4.27 million existing homes available for sale. That represents
a 10.3-month supply in comparison with a 10.7-month supply in
October. "Inventory is still high, and further reduction
in prices may be required in some areas to induce buyers back
into the market," Yun said. As for single-family homes alone,
sales rose 0.7 percent, though 19.9 percent below one year earlier;
the median was $208,700, off 3.7 percent. Condos and co-ops had
sales slip by 1.6 percent from October and BY 20.6 percent from
November 2006; the median was $221,100, down 0.7 percent.
OCTOBER
PRICES SLID IN 19 OF 25 METRO AREAS
The latest
monthly report by Radar Logic disclosed that only three of the
25 Metropolitan Statistical Areas
(MSAs) tracked by the company showed increases in residential
price per square foot over the same period last year (Charlotte,
New York City and Seattle), three markets were neutral and 19
markets showed price declines. The results were roughly the opposite
the same period last year, when 14 markets showed an increase,
three markets were neutral and eight markets declined. The Miami
MSA declined 7.4 percent over the preceding 90 days and 3.5 percent
in just 30 days after rising 144.2 percent over five years. For
condos, the five leading markets (New York, Philadelphia, San
Francisco, Seattle and Milwaukee) had greater one-year increases
in price per square foot than their respective MSAs. All but Philadelphia
also were in the top five MSAs.
HOUSING
STARTS FELL 3.7 PERCENT IN NOVEMBER
Said NAHB Chief Economist
David Seiders: "It's no surprise that builders are
starting fewer homes and pulling fewer permits for new home construction
at a time when home buyer demand is weak and there's a heavy
supply of vacant homes on the market." U.S. Commerce Department
figures show that single-family housing starts declined 5.4 percent
in November to the lowest level since April of 1991. And permit
issuance for new single-family homes dropped 5.6 percent, their
lowest level since June of 1991.
The Big Apple
BREARLEY
GETS BRAWNY
A prestigious Upper
East Side girls school says it has a contract to buy part of an
adjacent apartment building and will relocate its rent-regulated
tenants to make way for classrooms, according to the New York
Post. Residents of the 12-story rear tower at 85 East End Ave.
have been wary for more than a year of expansion plans of the
elite Brearley School, whose alumnae include Caroline Kennedy
Schlossberg and actress Kyra Sedgwick. The school promised yesterday
to make moving easy for the tenants, who have said they pay less
than $2,000 monthly. State law bars the building's current owner,
BlackRock Realty, from evicting its rent-regulated tenants. But
the law exempts buildings owned by institutions "operated
exclusively for charitable or educational purposes." After
hearing of Brearley's interest in their building last year, tenants
lawyered up. The 12-story building's rear tower has 57 apartments,
of which 24 are already vacant, said a source familiar with the
deal.
A
NEW LAW GIVES CO-OPS A BREAK
The Mortgage Forgiveness
Debt Relief Act of 2007 modifies what is known as the 80-20 rule,
which co-ops must meet so that their shareholders can get the
same tax benefits as homeowners, says the New York Times. The
80-20 rule requires that no more than 20 percent of the co-op
corporation's gross income come from sources that are not
tenant-shareholders - usually, commercial tenants. Co-op lawyer
Dennis H. Greenstein noted that the measure, which went into effect
immediately, provided three ways for a co-op to ensure that tenant-shareholders
got the same tax treatment as homeowners. The first, he said,
is to comply with the original 80-20 rule. The second is for a
co-op to ensure that at least 80 percent of its total square footage
is used by tenant-shareholders for residential purposes. The third
is for a co-op to spend at least 90 percent of its total income
for the benefit of shareholders. "The second and third alternatives
are going to cover most co-op buildings with 80-20 problems,"
Greenstein said. "There will be a lot of buildings that
will benefit from it."
The Mortgage Biz
MORTGAGE
FRAUD IS OVERWHELMING PROSECUTORS
The number of mortgage
fraud cases has grown so fast that government agencies that investigate
and prosecute them cannot keep up, lenders and law enforcement
officials have said, reports the New York Times. Reports of suspected
mortgage fraud have doubled since 2005 and increased eightfold
since 2002. Banks filed 47,717 reports in 2007, up from 21,994
two years ago, according to statistics from the FBI and the Financial
Crimes Enforcement Network of the Treasury Department. In 2002,
banks
filed 5,623 reports. Mortgage fraud covers crimes like false statements
on mortgage applications and elaborate "flipping" schemes
that involve multiple properties and corrupt appraisers, title
companies and straw buyers. Law enforcement agencies say they
are overwhelmed, especially because investigating and prosecuting
fraud can be complex and time consuming. The officials say career
criminals and organized-crime rings have increasingly turned from
other crimes to mortgage fraud because it offers lower risks and
high profits. Losses involving federally insured banks totaled
$813 million in the 2007 fiscal year, more than double the $293
million lost in the 2002 fiscal year. These figures most likely
represent "the tip of the iceberg," said the Mortgage
Bankers Association, an industry group, because they do not cover
mortgage brokers, who arrange more than half of new mortgages.
The industry estimates the total loss this year at $4 billion.
And the Wall Street Journal notes that such fraud goes a long
way toward explaining why mortgage defaults and foreclosures are
rocking financial institutions, Wall Street and the economy. In
2006, losses from fraud could total a record $4.5 billion, a 100
percent increase from the previous year, says Arthur Prieston,
chairman of the Prieston Group, which provides lenders with mortgage-fraud
insurance and training. "We've created a culture where a
great many people know how to take advantage of the system,"
said Prieston.
LICENSING
FOR MORTGAGE BROKERS PICKS UP STEAM
A nationwide licensing
system that's intended to help states track mortgage brokers and
lenders under their jurisdiction launched this week with seven
states participating and 31 more expected to join by the end of
next year, says Inman News. The Nationwide Mortgage Licensing
System (NMLS) creates a single file for each state-regulated mortgage
lender, broker, branch and loan originator, simplifying the process
of licensing and monitoring companies and individuals who do business
in more than one state. First proposed in 2004, the NMLS launched
with New York, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Idaho, Iowa, Kentucky
and Nebraska on board. All told, 38 states, plus Washington, D.C.,
and Puerto Rico, have committed to participate in the system by
the end of 2009. Members of the National Association of Mortgage
Brokers have complained that the system excludes originators at
banks and other federally regulated financial institutions.
LOAN
APPLICATIONS ARE ON THE DECLINE
For the Christmas
holiday shortened week ending Dec. 28, volume was 11.6 percent
below the previous week on a seasonally adjusted basis, according
to the Mortgage Bankers Association. On an unadjusted basis, the
decrease was 47.2 percent; it was off 20 percent compared with
the same week one year earlier. Refinancings decreased 15.4 percent,
and purchase applications dropped 8.5 percent. Unadjusted, the
loan volume for purchases declined 44.9 percent from the previous
week. The refinance share of mortgage activity fell to 50.9 percent
of total applications from 53.0, while the adjustable-rate mortgage
(ARM) share slipped to 9.8 from 10.4 percent of the total.
SPENDING
ON RESIDENTIAL CONSTRUCTION CONTINUES TO FALL
The rate of such spending
fell for the 21st consecutive month in November, the U.S. Census
Bureau reported, says Inman News. It dropped 17.8 percent compared
with the previous November. The seasonally adjusted annual rate
of spending on private residential construction projects was $484.9
billion, 30.3 percent lower than the record peak rate of $696
billion in February 2006.
RATES
DIP TO FOUR-WEEK LOW
The 30-year fixed-rate
mortgage (FRM) averaged 6.07 percent for the week, down from last
week’s 6.17 percent and 6.18 percent last year at this time,
says Freddie Mac. The 15-year FRM this week was 5.68 percent versus
5.79 percent last week and 5.94 percent last year. Five-year Treasury-indexed
hybrid adjustable-rate mortgages (ARMs) were 5.78 percent, down
from 5.90 percent; a year ago, they averaged 6.02 percent. One-year
Treasury-indexed ARMs were 5.47 percent in comparison with last
week’s 5.53 percent and last year’s 5.42 percent.
The Soothsayers
ONLY
MODEST IMPROVEMENT, IF ANY, SEEN THIS YEAR
It's difficult to
get a consensus on exactly when housing will turn the corner,
the Wall Street Journal reports. Local markets will certainly
vary, but at the least it's likely that some of the same problems
that plagued 2007 will carry over into next year, the newspaper
finds. At best, market conditions could start to
stabilize, with home sales regaining strength. If more buyers
get back into the market, some of the huge inventories of new
and existing homes for sale can begin to be worked off. "The
only reason why demand is finding a bottom is because sellers
are cutting their prices," said Mark Zandi, chief economist
of Moody's Economy.com. "There was a sense that the market
would cool - I don't think there was a sense it would crash. And
it crashed." The National Association of Realtors predicts
a slight increase in existing-home sales next year but a decline
in new-home sales. Others aren't as optimistic, including the
Mortgage Bankers Association, which is predicting that sales won't
pick up until 2009. The home price drops encouraged a number of
people to put home buying decisions on hold. In some of the most
sluggish markets, sellers who don't absolutely need to sell aren't
attempting to do so; those who do are offering price cuts and
concessions to make the deal. "A hallmark of the downturn
is how broad it is across the country," said Zandi. But even
in poor-performing markets there could be good neighborhoods,
he said, adding that housing conditions vary "block to block."
Research
ONCE
AGAIN, NEVADA TOPS THIS LIST
It returned as the
nation's fastest-growing state, with a population increase
of 2.9 percent in the year ending last July 1, according to estimates
by the U.S. Census Bureau. Arizona, fastest-growing between 2005
and 2006, slipped to second place, while Louisiana began to rebound
from its post-Hurricane Katrina population loss, gaining nearly
50,000 residents for a total population of 4.3 million. The state
lost 250,000 residents during the previous one-year period. Texas
gained more people than any other state; its increase of almost
500,000 was ahead of runner-up California, which added slightly
more than 300,000. The New York Times said the bursting housing
bubble had squelched expansion in some of the nation's fastest-growing
states during the year reported by the Census bureau. The newspaper
went on to say that Wyoming bumped Florida from the list of the
top 10 fastest-growing states. Only 35,000 Americans moved to
Florida from elsewhere in the United States, compared with nearly
five times as many the year before. Michigan and Rhode Island
registered their second consecutive annual losses in population,
and the outflow of residents from high-cost states like California,
New York, New Jersey and Massachusetts to more affordable states
slowed last year.
ANGIE'S
LIST FORESEES INCREASED REMODELING
According to the popular
home-repair referral service, Angie's List, its annual poll
indicates that home owners will spend an average of $11,250 on
home improvement and maintenance projects in 2008, up 13 percent
over the average they reported spending in 2007, says Realtor
magazine. Homeowners responding to the unscientific survey say
they plan to spend 2.9 percent of their home's value on
repairs and renovations this year (implying a belief that their
homes are worth $387,931). "Building experts tell us they're
getting calls for work from home owners who would otherwise move
and put their current home on the market, but are afraid they
can't sell it quickly enough to afford the newer, bigger
house," says Angie's List founder Angie Hicks. The
most frequently planned projects are kitchen and bath updates
- areas that real estate experts say provide the best return when
selling a home.
This and That
CONGRESS
GIVES A BREAK TO SURVIVING SPOUSES
Until now, widows
and widowers had only until the end of the year in which their
spouses died to take advantage of $500,000 in exclusion of capital
gains taxes by selling their property. The exclusion dropped to
$250,000 if the sale occurred in the next year. Just before recess,
the Congress enacted a new two-year deadline.
NOT
ONLY STOCKS CAN BE BLUE-CHIP, SAYS FORBES
It found that properties
in some well-established neighborhoods have held onto and increased
in value over the last 17 years. They include segments of Pacific
Palisades in Los Angeles, areas of Chicago and
parts of University Park in Dallas. In these spots, the median
home sale price has grown by 440 percent, 236 percent and 148
percent, respectively. In some cases, the magazine's blue-chip
picks encompass a city's priciest area - for example, in New York,
where a swath of the Upper East Side in the east 70s was found
valuable in 1990 and has appreciated by 325 percent since then.
Of course, stability and strong, consistent growth gets cooked
into the neighborhood's $2.45 million median home price tag. Another
consideration for some blue-chip areas: the range of housing prices.
In the Embassy Row section of Washington, D.C., there's little
available much below the $2.84 million median price. But head
to the Walnut Street and Third Street section of Philadelphia,
and you'll find townhouses listing above $2 million, but about
30 percent of the homes for sale are available for between $340,000
and $670,000.
DOES
LOOKING AT YOUR FIREPLACE BURN YOU UP
For less than $300,
consider painting the existing brick and/or the interior of the
firebox, suggests the Washington Post. (For the latter, use high-heat
paint.) Then replace a worn or dated fire screen and tools to
harmonize with other furnishings. For under $1,000, you can replace
a damaged or dated tile hearth with a slab of slate, granite or
other stone. Or you can add a new or vintage fireplace surround
or mantel, or replace one that is outdated or poorly proportioned.
With $5,000 or less, box in the existing brick or stone with drywall
and paint, then enlarge and reface the surround and mantel, or
both, with simple custom carpentry, porcelain or limestone tiles,
mirror, stone (real or fake) or poured concrete. Do you have more
than $5,000 for your fireplace? Face the entire fireplace with
exotic stone or elaborate custom millwork and acquire an antique
fireplace surround, preferably ornately carved marble or rare
wood from a centuries-old French chateau, English manor house
or Italian villa. For other fireplace facelift ideas, check out
"Fire Spaces: Design Inspirations for Fireplaces and Stoves,"
by Tina Skinner (Schiffer Publishing, 2003, $34.95).
ECONOMISTS
SAY HOUSE PRICES AND RENTS ARE OUT OF WHACK
U.S. house prices
"likely would have to fall considerably" to return to
a normal relationship with rents, says a study by one former and
two current Federal Reserve economists, reports the Wall Street
Journal. The study suggests prices would have to fall 15 percent
over five years, assuming rents rose 4 percent a year. House prices
would have to fall further if the adjustment took place more quickly.
Going back to 1960, the study found annual rents fluctuated at
around 5-5.25 percent of home prices until 1995, when the average
monthly rent was about $553 (or about $6,600 a year) and the average
home price was about $134,000. But starting in 1996, home prices
started to grow much more rapidly than rents. By the end of 2006,
they had more than doubled to an average of $282,000, while the
average rent had risen 48 percent to $818, creating an annual
rent/price ratio of 3.48 percent. (That means the rent/price ratio
is about a third below its long-term average.) The paper suggests
house prices would need to fall about 3 percent a year, if rents
grew in line with their 4 percent average annual growth this decade
to return to a normal ratio. The U.S. study is by Morris Davis,
an economist at the University of Wisconsin-Madison and until
2006 a staff economist at the Fed; and Andreas Lehnert and Robert
F. Martin, staff economists at the Fed. Davis told the Journal
that only rapid growth in growth in rents could justify current
price levels. But it's hard to imagine the scenario that would
justify such rapid growth in rents, he added. Indeed, it's possible
rents will grow more slowly than 4 percent, reflecting the overhang
of unsold homes that might be rented out. The authors postulated
a five-year horizon for the rent/price ratio to return to normal
by looking at previous downturns, Davis said, observing that "when
a downturn begins, it will last for a while."
Boldface
A
PRODUCER'S ONETIME ESTATE COULD PRODUCE REAL CASH
A Southampton, N.Y.,
estate formerly owned by Martin "Marty" Richards, who
produced the Oscar-winning 2002 film "Chicago" and many
Broadway plays, has just gone on the market for $65 million, reports
the Wall Street Journal. The current owner, a European businessman,
paid Richards $23 million for the estate in 2003 and spent more
than $25 million overhauling the property. The six-acre oceanfront
estate on Gin Lane includes a 13,000-square-foot, eight-bedroom
main house and a 7,500-square-foot "guest house" with
three bedroom suites, staff quarters and a four-car garage. With
more than 400 feet on the ocean, the grounds include a pool and
spa, a self-watering clay tennis court and a lily pond, presumably
not self-watering.
SEAN
CONNERY, MEET JUDGE NO
A Manhattan judge has
had enough of a court feud between the actor and his neighbor
and is urging the James Bond star and his real-life arch-enemy
Dr. Sultan to make peace, according to the New York Post. Manhattan
Supreme Court Justice Marcy Friedman chided Connery and his family
for their "blunderbuss" court attacks on eye doctor
Burton Sultan and his family, but she fined Sultan $1,000 for
repeatedly filing lawsuits on claims he's already lost. "Regrettably,
both parties to this dispute have engaged in a 'slash and burn'
litigation strategy," Friedman wrote. She threw out the bulk
of the Sultans' claims against the Connerys and several contractors
who have worked on the East 71st Street building the families
share. The Sultans blame the Connerys and their workers for trashing
the condo, causing leaks and other damage to the home they share
with their two adult daughters. The Connerys blame the Sultans
for blocking them from completing necessary repair work on the
townhouse's roof, which they say is jeopardizing their safety
and giving them higher repair costs. They've filed about 10 lawsuits
against each other. In one of Sultan's, he called Connery a "rude,
foul-mouthed, fat old man" who plays "loud music all
the time while stomping about" the apartment. The judge's
ruling bars both sides from filing any other suits without her
permission. The ruling does not, however, bar Connery from stomping
about.
A
MANSION THAT CHARLIE WILSON VISITED IS ON THE MARKET
A Houston mansion
originally owned by a socialite who figures prominently in the
film "Charlie Wilson's War" has gone on the market for
$3.5 million., says the Wall Street Journal. Joanne King Herring,
the politically active Texan who had the house built, is played
by Julia Roberts in the film. In 1954, Ms. Herring built the four-bedroom,
5,500-square-foot house on nearly 4.5 acres in a French baroque
style. There's a large ballroom with wood paneling decorated with
gilded bronze cherubs, violins and lyres. Herring and her first
husband, Robert King, hosted Princess Grace and Prince Rainier
of Monaco in 1968, among many others, including Wilson. The sellers,
Cesar Rodriguez and his wife, Magdalena, bought the home about
seven years ago.
HE'S
HOT, BEAUTIFUL AND VERY MUCH IN DEBT
A Harvard MBA, an
entrepreneur, a corporate lecturer and the runner-up on the first
season of "The Apprentice," Kwame Jackson is about to
lose his triplex condo in Harlem, reports the New York Post. According
to papers filed with the city, a lien has been placed on Jackson's
West 123rd Street apartment in Manhattan for nonpayment of common
charges of more than $12,000 dating back to April 2006. "We've
had a few payments in the past," the building's lawyer, Lisa
Breier Urban, said, "but nothing has come in for the last
eight months." Jackson, one of People magazine's 50 Most
Beautiful People and 50 Hottest Bachelors, could not be reached.
Out
and About
The
Reality of Realty Today
Manhattan may be an
island in the literal sense, and it may feel that way even more
so from the perspective of the national housing market. In truth,
however, it already seems to be acting more like a peninsula than
an island.
Faithful readers of
the market information that is published here every two weeks
and regularly in local newspapers could not help but notice that
the Manhattan market has changed, however much in denial sellers
may be. Ever hopeful that the market will tank, buyers, on the
other hand, undoubtedly are hanging onto every shred of bad news;
as a result, they are hanging onto a white-picket fence of decision
making. Understandably uncertain whether now is the time to buy
or wait for a bust, they are seemingly oblivious to two certainties:
1. Market timing is almost always folly, whether in stocks, bonds,
currencies, pork belly futures or housing, and 2. Other uncertainties
such as lending rates easily can offset any benefit of timing
the market correctly.
As the New York Times
has pointed out, there is a growing chasm between the prices that
sellers are setting for their properties and their value in today's
market, causing buyers to dig in their heels against intransigent
property owners. In addition, the subtext of this and many recent
Out and About columns is that a wealth of apartments and townhouses
is obviously overpriced. And data previously published here from
Radar Logic, where appraisal executive Jonathan Miller of Miller
Samuel issues highly respected analysis, already demonstrates
that price acceleration has steeply declined in Manhattan. In
fact, the median actually fell 1.7 percent between the third and
fourth quarters of 2007, as reported in the story below. Miller
is forecasting very modest increases this year, and the possibility
is that prices will remain flat at best. (One important imponderable
is whether the trend of declining inventory will abate.)
Consider what Alfred
Renna of Prudential Douglas Elliman found in his analysis of sales
at the company's biggest office during the first half of
December - hardly a scientific assessment but perhaps telling.
Fully 60 percent of the sales were below the asking price versus
50 percent the prior month. The discounts were 2.4 percent below
the original price and 2 percent below the most recently reduced
price. At the same time, median days on the market once the price
was ultimately reduced increased over the previous month -
from 46 to 56 days, 22 percent longer. Finally, inventory continued
to slide, slipping by 3 percent.
Why are properties
consistently offered too high? Sellers' expectations obviously
have not caught up with the status of the market. Worse, they
are enabled by those brokers who will agree to list an apartment
or townhouse for too much money just to get the listing, knowing
that the owner eventually will get tired of preparing for open
houses, vacating their residences for visitors at inconvenient
times and waiting interminably to collect the proceeds of selling.
(That questionable tactic is called 'buying the listing.')
The right price of a property that is marketed correctly brings
virtual certainty of a relatively swift sale, and smart sellers
act accordingly. Those whose expectations are out of synch with
the market, refusing to face reality, are doomed to learn the
hard way that no block, neighborhood or county is entirely removed
from the rest of the country.
Moreover, the psychological
impact of bad news elsewhere exerts a more powerful effect on
a buyer even than any bonus or any emotional response to the home
of his or her dreams. And if the perception persists that the
market is tanking, buyers develop the belief that if they lose
a property for which they make a lowball offer, there will be
another at least as good just around the corner. Forget the bidding
wars of yore, except for the most desirable and well priced properties.
Mass psychology knows no bounds, and no market is an island.
Now, a sampling of
properties that various brokers are marketing and that have been
seen since the last issue:
Upper
West Side
- A pleasantly traditional
two-bedroom, one-and-a-half bath condo on the third floor of
a pre-war pet-friendly building undergoing a rolling conversion.
This 1,285-sf apartment, which has been painted and otherwise
slightly improved, has a standard kitchen, full dining room,
decent closet space, high ceilings, refinished herringbone floors
and views of brick walls, is listed too high at $1.25 million
with maintenance of $837 monthly.
- Only half a dozen
blocks south of Columbia University, a sweet co-op of approximately
750 square feet in a small building with typically well-worn
public spaces. But this technically one-bedroom unit with open
exposures only from the living room has a certain charm -
modestly modernized open kitchen with breakfast counter, French
doors leading to a room that could be used as an office, den
or second bedroom, exposed brick in the living room, hardwood
flooring that is original for the most part and an improved
bath with claw-foot tub in a pre-war pet-friendly building with
live-in super. It is priced correctly at $675,000 with monthly
maintenance of $821.
- Going
fast. An impressively gut-renovated corner co-op
that was transformed several years ago from seven and a half
rooms to five with numerous flourishes, including Venetian plaster,
crown and dentil molding beneath 11.5-foot ceilings, wood-burning
fireplace, 31-foot-long living room, handsome high-end eat-in
kitchen, beautiful built-ins, a washer/dryer, custom sound system,
central air conditioning and excellent flooring of hardwood
and marble, the latter in an entry hallway or gallery that extends
almost too long for two-thirds the length of this 1,700-sf apartment.
At $2.5 million with maintenance of $1,493 a month, this superb
six-floor unit is listed at a fair price.
- With two bedrooms
and one and a half baths (each in need of improvement), a way
overpriced 1,200-sf pre-war co-op that has languished on the
market for more than a year. The kitchen - which, because of
a SubZero refrigerator and white-tiled walls, sounds better
than it looks - is cramped, cheesy and seemingly impossible
to expand. The hardwood floors are disgrace, the dining room
is aptly described as a dinette, and the only open exposure
is from one north-facing bedroom. Even at $999,000 with maintenance
of $1,300 per month, this apartment is offered at $150,000 too
much.
- A lovely three-bedroom,
two-and-half-bath apartment with maids room, well-designed open
kitchen, laundry room complete with Neptune appliances, and
high ceilings. Fashioned from two units in a Rosario Candela
building a stone's throw from Riverside Park, this totally
renovated co-op features a 22' x 23' living room,
built-in bookcases and plenty of closets. The listing price
of $2.5 million maintenance of $1,875 monthly is on target.
East
Side
- On Carnegie Hill,
a pleasantly updated first-floor apartment with windows facing
other nearby buildings, one bedroom, separate breakfast room
or even small bedroom, good closet space, high ceilings, hardwood
floors, skim-coated walls, an improved all-white dual-entry
bath and a newer kitchen, albeit with laminate countertops.
In a pet-friendly pre-war building with only a live-in super
as an amenity, this 825-sf co-op is offered at $699,000 with
maintenance of $832 a month. The price is stated as "negotiable,"
and that represents a reduction in November from $725,000, which
was the amount when the place first was listed in early October.
What does that tell you?
- Hanging
on. An alcove studio with open views east from
the 16th floor. The 525-sf post-war co-op has excellent closet
space, an elevated platform in front on the windows, a small
functional kitchen with diminutive appliances, old parquet floors
and a dated bath. At $430,000 with monthly maintenance of $581
in a pet-friendly building with full-time doorman, this apartment
remains overpriced - even after a reduction from $450,000 when
it went on the market last August.
- Another post-war
apartment, this one a one-bedroom condo in a 1984 building with
a wide spectrum of amenities including a garage and indoor pool.
The 15th-floor unit has a pass-through kitchen with stainless
appliances and laminate countertops, a bath with marble floors
and sink (each with stains), moderately customized closets and
small balcony. But views east are partially obstructed by a
high-rise immediately opposite. Offered in October at an unlikely
$725,000 with common charges of $497 per month, the apartment
now has had its price ratcheted down to a more reasonable $599,000.
- Losing
hope. On the edge of East Harlem, two similar
co-ops in similar adjoining 15-unit pre-war buildings. The one-bedroom
apartments of possibly 475 to 575 square feet respectively are
similarly grim, featuring in one case views only of an airshaft
from low floors. The smaller unit, listed at $295,000 with $500
in monthly maintenance since October, needs to be gut renovated
and, even so, has no potential. It supposedly went under a contract
that fell through for $250,000. The other, slightly improved
apartment, which went on the market a year ago for $320,000,
has as its sole redeeming qualities a large window facing the
street and shabby renovations. It is said to have gone under
contract at one point for its current asking price of $275,000
with maintenance of $500.
Manhattan
4th Quarter Results
From There to Infinity?
The median sales price
of apartments increased 6.4 percent to $850,000 over the prior
year quarter result of $799,000, but it was1.7 percent below the
preceding quarter's $864,397, according to a report by the
Miller Samuel appraisal firm for Prudential Douglas Elliman. The
average price per square foot increased 18.2 percent to a record
$1,180 over the prior year quarter's $998; it was 3.1 percent
above the previous quarter's $1,144. Inflated by an influx
of very high-end condos such as 15 Central Park West and the Plaza
Hotel, the average sales price grew by 17.6 percent to a record
$1,439,909 since the last quarter of 2006 and by 5.1 percent over
the third quarter of 2007. Other highlights of the report:
- The number of sales
increased 3.2 percent this quarter to 2,518 units as compared
with the 2,441 units sold in the prior year quarter.
- Listing inventory
fell 13.5 percent to 5,133 units from the prior year quarter
total of 5,934 units.
- The number of days
on the market was 131 days this quarter versus 149 days in the
same period last year and 123 days in the preceding quarter.
- The listing discount
was 2.7 percent, essentially unchanged from 2.8 percent in the
same period last year, but higher than the previous quarter's
2 percent.
Co-ops
- The median sales
price was $675,000, up 3.8 percent from 2006.
- The average price
per square foot increased 21 percent, and the average sales
price increased 9.1 percent from the same period last year,
reflecting higher price gains at the upper end of the market.
- Inventory levels
fell 26.2 percent to 2,254 units as compared with the prior
year quarter total of 3,054 units.
Condos
- The median sales
price was $1,100,000, up 6.8 percent from the previous year.
- The average price
per square foot rose 10.6 percent, and the sales price averaged
17.8 percent more than the prior year quarter because of extraordinarily
high prices and sales at the upper end of the market.
- Inventory levels
were unchanged at 2,879 units, with new development added to
the market offsetting a decline in re-sale listings.
Luxury
Market
(Upper 10 percent of all co-op and condo sales)
- The median sales
price of a luxury apartment was a record $4.3 million, an increase
of 28.4 percent over the fourth quarter of 2006 and 8.9 percent
over the third quarter of 2007.
- The average price
per square foot and average sales price recorded respective
29.8 percent and 32.8 percent gains over the prior year quarter.
Loft
Market
(Co-op and condo sales)
- The median sales
price was $1.445 million, 3.6 percent higher than in 2006.
- The average price
per square foot rose 18.3 percent, and the average sales price
went up 11.3 percent from the prior year quarter, thanks to
increased activity at the upper end of the market.
New
Listings
Some
of Manhattan's Latest Listings
Please
click
here to view available properties. (To view all photos, tours,
floor plans and maps, please use Internet Explorer.)
Click
Here to Sign Up For Your Free Issue
of Realty Digest!
Archived
Newsletters

©
2007 Service You Can Trust
|